#197, CarInsurance.com picks cheapest, best companies

James Raia

Ashlee Tilford is the managing editor of QuinStreet.com, the marketing and search engine service company. It recently released a consumer-based post detailing a new study by CarInsurance.com — the cheapest and best car insurance companies.

Tilford is our guest this week on The Weekly Driver Podcast. Co-hosts Bruce Aldrich and James Raia discuss with Tilford the CarInsurance.com, one of QuinStreet.com’s companies, compiled the resource guide.

CarInsurance.com has picked the best and cheapest auto rates.
CarInsurance.com has picked the best and cheapest auto rates.

While considering what’s available in major and small auto insurance companies, the report includes information vetted by experts in several categories, including driver’s age, location and driving habits.

“We compared rates among 35 different insurance providers,” Tilford explains. “But before we did that, we created 11 different driver profiles because almost anybody is going to find into one or more of those categories or someone on their policy probably will.”

Car Insurance: Different Rates, Different Drivers

Tilford explains the categories were established to relate to consumers to see what should be expected for “whatever their driver profile is.”

The study shows good value insurance options considering various categories: comprehensive coverage, drivers with speeding tickets, drivers with poor credit, drivers with accidents, student and teenage drivers and low-mileage drivers.

Tilford also provides insight into some of the controversial areas insurance companies use to determine rates, including credit score and marital status.

“I compare credit scores to high school GPAs or even college GPAs,” says Tilford. “People said ‘when you get out there in the real world, your GPA isn’t going to be that big of a deal. Nobody is going to care about that. Credit scores are similar.

“We can shuffle them under the rug and we can ignore them for a long time. But when they do start affecting us and they do, that is when it becomes apparent how important it is. Your credit score absolutely impacts your auto insurance rates.”

Please join us on Episode #197. Our guest provides knowledge and a jovial approach to what is often a mundane but integral part of car ownership.

The Weekly Driver Podcast encourages and appreciates feedback from our listeners. Please forward episode links to family, friends and colleagues. And you are welcome to repost links from the podcast to your social media accounts. The idea of more eyeballs on more content works for us.

Support our podcast by shopping on Amazon.com. A graphic display at the bottom of the post links to automotive selections of the online retailer. But there’s also a search function for anything available directly from the site.

If you shop via this site, we receive a small commission. It helps us continue to produce independent content. The site began in 2004 and includes more than 700 reviews.

The podcast is approaching its fourth , and we’ve had a diverse collection of guests — famous athletes, vintage car collectors, manufacturer CEOs, automotive book authors, industry analysts, a movie stuntman and episodes from auto shows and car auctions.

Please send comments and suggestions for new episodes to James Raia via email: [email protected].

All podcast episodes are archived on theweeklydriver.com/podcast

Every episode is also available on your preferred podcast platform. Several of the more prominent platforms are listed below.


If you enjoy our podcast, please also consider supporting the hosts by buying us a cup of coffee. Visit the cup of coffee icon below. Make a one-time donation or a monthly contribution.


Article Last Updated: October 8, 2021.

Leave a Reply

Share to...